News

AI Drives Misleadingly Positive MD&A in Quarterly Reports—Securities Litigation Likely to Emerge

Blurb: A new study finds that public companies are increasingly using positive language in their quarterly MD&A reports to influence AI-driven analysis, even when financial results are poor. This trend raises concerns about misleading disclosures and the potential for future securities litigation.

In a recent study, Keren Bar-Hava, head of the accounting department at Hebrew University Business School, reveals a significant shift in how public companies craft their quarterly Management Discussion and Analysis (MD&A) reports included within their financial statements. (See here WJS Opinion article summarizing her study at: Quarterly Reports Are Written for AI – WSJ , Paywall).

Traditionally written to inform investors, these MD&A reports are now increasingly tailored to appeal to artificial intelligence (AI) algorithms. As a reaction to AI analysis, MD&A sections have become notably more positive in tone, especially when actual outcomes are bad. Companies are strategically using optimistic language to influence how AI interprets their disclosures, even when financial performance is declining.

With the advent of advanced AI tools like ChatGPT, analyzing MD&A sections for trends in tone, complexity, and word choice has become a task that can be accomplished in seconds. This technological leap has led companies to adapt their reporting strategies, knowing that their reports are being scrutinized by machines before reaching human eyes.

Bar-Hava identifies three types of AI-induced disclosure pressure influencing corporate reporting:

  1. Exposure Pressure: AI tools flag vague or evasive language, pushing companies to project confidence even in uncertain times.
  2. Competitive Pressure: Algorithms compare the tone of reports across peer firms, making companies strive to sound stronger than their competitors.
  3. Reputational Pressure: AI-driven insights feed into analyst dashboards and investor platforms, where a poorly framed sentence can have widespread repercussions.

Bar-Hava’s study of 108 MD&A reports from 27 top U.S. firms between 2021 and 2024 found a notable trend: the use of positive language has increased, even when financial performance declined. This contrasts with earlier studies that showed a more cautious tone during periods of poor performance. Now, words like “growth,” “resilient,” and “opportunity” have become more common, while terms indicating uncertainty have diminished. Interestingly, the most positive reports often came from the worst-performing firms, suggesting a strategic use of tone to influence AI interpretations.

This shift poses a risk of creating a gap between the optimistic language used in reports and the actual financial reality. While the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has made strides in encouraging clear and concise narrative disclosure, the regulation of tone remains a blind spot. As AI-driven tone scores increasingly influence market behavior, there is a growing need to treat tone as a material disclosure element.

Bar-Hava argues that boards must recognize they are writing for both human and machine audiences. Since machines interpret the text literally, the inflation of positive tone can mislead investors. To ensure truth in reporting, it is crucial to monitor not just what is said, but how it is said.

While we have not yet seen securities litigation premised on misleading tone, given the growing gap between reality and language Bar-Hava warns of, the current use of AI to influence MD&A sections may mean that such lawsuits may inevitably be forthcoming. Such a gap is exactly what plaintiffs and plaintiffs’ attorneys seek to find and correct, and they will be aided by AI tools themselves in doing so.

Joseph Wilson

Joseph Wilson is a veteran journalist with a keen interest in covering the dynamic worlds of technology, business, and entrepreneurship.

Recent Posts

Firmware-Level Threats in Consumer Smartphones: Supply Chain Risks and Hardware Malware Implications

Security Advisory 2025-NUB-SEC-001 A subset of the nubia Z6255CA series devices has been identified as…

1 hour ago

Cybernetis AI Launches Predictive Analytics Platform for Mid-Sized Retailers

Cybernetis AI today announced the launch of a new predictive analytics platform designed to make…

21 hours ago

Healthcare SaaS Brand Solutionreach Breaks The B2B Mold With Long-Form, Story-Driven Ad Campaign

In celebration of its 25th year in business, leading healthcare SaaS brand Solutionreach stepped boldly…

21 hours ago

Oregon RIA Founder Brent Pearson Unveils Turnkey Crypto Sub-Advisory Platform

New Firm Solves 'Held-Away' Asset Problem for Financial Advisors with Institutional-Grade, Insured Cold Storage Solution.…

21 hours ago

NVBDC Services Committee Resources Webinar with the United Nations

The National Veteran Business Development Council (NVBDC) Services Committee, led by NVBDC Board Member and Services Committee…

21 hours ago

Finjobsly.com Debuts Revolutionary AI Platform to Solve Fintech’s Talent Crisis

First-to-Market AI Platform Emerges as the Definitive Job Board for the $515 Billion Fintech Sector…

21 hours ago

This website uses cookies.